Lesson 5: Faulkner's The Sound and the Fury: April Eighth, 1928: Narrating from an 'Ordered Place'?

• Review the curriculum unit overview and the lesson plan. Locate and bookmark suggested materials. If necessary, download and print out any documents you will use and duplicate copies as necessary for student viewing.
• Students can access the novel and some of the activity materials via the Study Activity.
• This lesson will cover only chapter four, although students will be expected to read the entire novel closely. If you are using this lesson as a stand-alone lesson, be sure to review with students Activity 1: Introduction to Faulkner's South from the first lesson of this curriculum unit, Faulkner's The Sound the the Fury: Introduction.

Activity 1. First to Third Person Point of View: Compare and Contrast

As preparation for class discussion, or as an in-class activity, ask students to revisit the completed point of view chart from Lesson Three, and complete the columns for the Dilsey chapter.

Then, ask students to compare and contrast the use of first person point of view in either the Benjy, Quentin, and Jason chapters and the use of a third person omniscient narrator in the final chapter (teachers might ask that students write about this in their reading journals, or use this comparison as the opening for a class discussion). Consider asking students some or all of the following questions:

• How does this chapter's point of view differ from the other three chapters?
• What do you learn about the Compson family from this chapter's narrator?
• According to the narrator of this chapter, how has the Compson family changed?
• According to the narrator of this chapter, how has the South changed?
• What do you learn from this narrator about Caddy?

Collect the worksheets at the end of this activity.

In class, students will also discuss their general response to this chapter. The use of the omniscient third person not only helps to shed light on the novel's basic plot, it helps to reveal key themes as well. To bring students closer to understanding the novel's primary themes, ask students to develop one thesis statement detailing a theme of the novel. Their thesis should be supported by three or four quotes from the novel, which they should copy into their reading journal for easy reference during class discussion.

Activity 2. The Novel's Frame

In the final paragraph of the novel proper (not including Faulkner's 1946 Appendix), Faulkner writes:

"Ben's voice roared and roared. Queenie moved again, her feet began to clop-clop steadily again, and at once Ben hushed. Luster looked quickly back over his shoulder, then he drove on. The broken flower drooped over Ben's fist and his eyes were empty and blue and serene again as cornice and façade flowed smoothly once more from left to right, post and tree, window and doorway and signboard each in its ordered place."

The novel, therefore, brings us full circle to Benjy, who sees the world in black/white, clear-cut terms based on what object passes his line of vision at any given moment. In this final scene, Jason has ordered Luster and Benjy to "'Get to hell on home'" from the square where the "Confederate soldier gazed with empty eyes."

From Benjy's black/white perspective of the world—a perspective that generates meaning externally as objects literally pass by Benjy's line of vision—each element of the approaching house's façade has an "ordered place." While the Compson house and the other aristocratic houses encountered along the way seem sturdy and stable, inside each one families such as the Compson's are in turmoil. Seeing the ordered house from the outside, readers, at the novel's end, realize that the Compson family has reached it final point of decline. And it is Dilsey who says ""I seed de beginning, en now I sees de endin."

Now that students also can see the end of the novel, ask them to think about the different ways that Faulkner uses time. Ask each student (or group of students) to quickly draw up a timeline of events. If they have been keeping track of a timeline as part of the Assessment activities, they can refer to that assignment instead. As students share their chronologies, they should eventually describe the three ways that Faulkner structures time in The Sound and the Fury:

• Chronological Time (Easter weekend, and Quentin's chapter 18 years prior)
• Narrative Time (the order the story is told: Benjy, Quentin, Jason, Dilsey)
• Time in Reflection on Past Events (the amount of time each individual character spends in reflection on past events, the order of which roughly corresponds to Narrative Time).

Share this 2D graph of Chronological and Narrative time, available as part of the supporting materials from the hypertext edition of The Sound and the Fury. This graph shows that Chronological time in the novel puts Benjy's beginning chapter in the middle of Easter weekend (April 7), preceded by Jason (April 6) and followed by the narrator of the fourth chapter (April 8) on Easter Sunday. As the note on the graph indicates, Faulkner then situates the action of the novel in medias res, or "into the middle of things" by beginning with Benjy's chapter.

Next, turn to the 3D graph of Time, also available from the hypertext edition of The Sound and the Fury. Note the blue line, which reveals that amount of time each character spends in reflection on the past through memories and flashbacks. Easter Sunday is when Dilsey declares that now she "sees de endin."

To reconnect this broad overview to the specific chapter discussions, ask students to recall earlier discussions of memory and time and compare how characters spend their time in reflection:

• Who reflects on the past the most? The least?
• How do the characters vary in their process of reflection?
• Is there a difference in their attitudes towards the past?
• Is there a difference in how they mentally approach the past (deliberately, through associations or flashbacks, with or without regret or longing)?
• What do you think Faulkner is suggesting about memory and the process of memory? Is memory different for each person? Can several people see the past in different ways?
• Do any characters project a vision for the future?

Activity 3. Concluding the Novel

Taking into consideration the following quotes, lead a class discussion to wrap up the novel (guiding questions follow quotes). An instructor can either lead a general class discussion, or pass a quotation out to groups with guiding questions as a small group activity.

Useful quotes:

'You'd better do as he [Jason] says,' Mrs. Compson said. 'He's head of the house now. It's his right to require us to respect his wishes.'"
"You, Jason!" Mrs Compson said. "He will never find the right one," she said. "You know I never let anyone take my keys, Dilsey," she said. She began to wail.
"Hush," Dilsey said. "He aint gwine do nothin to her. I aint gwine let him."
"But on Sunday morning, in my own house," Mrs Compson said. "When I've tried so hard to raise them christians. Let me find the right key, Jason," she said. She put her hand on his arm. Then she began to struggle with him, but he flung her aside with a motion of his elbow and looked around at her for a moment, his eyes cold and harried, then he turned to the door again and the unwieldy keys.
"Hush," Dilsey said. "You, Jason!"
"Something terrible has happened," Mrs Compson said, wailing again. "I know it has. You, Jason," she said, grasping at him again. "He wont even let me find the key to a room in my own house!"
"Now, now," Dilsey said. "Whut kin happen? I right here. I aint gwine let him hurt her. Quentin," she said, raising her voice, "dont you be skeered, honey, I'se right here."
The door opened, swung inward. He stood in it for a moment, hiding the room, then he stepped aside. "Go in," he said in a thick, light voice. They went in. It was not a girl's room. It was not anybody's room, and the faint scent of cheap cosmetics and the few feminine objects and the other evidences of crude and hopeless efforts to feminise it but added to its anonymity, giving it that dead and stereotyped transience of rooms in assignation houses. The bed had not been disturbed. On the floor lay a soiled undergarment of cheap silk a little too pink, from a half open bureau drawer dangled a single stocking. The window was open. A pear tree grew there, close against the house. It was in bloom and the branches scraped and rasped against the house and the myriad air, driving in the window, brought into the room the forlorn scent of the blossoms.
"Dar now," Dilsey said. "Didn't I told you she all right?"
"All right?" Mrs Compson said. Dilsey followed her into the room and touched her.
"You come on and lay down, now," she said. "I find her in ten minutes."
 

Note that Dilsey holds power in the house. She is the protector against Jason.

"The clock tick-tocked, solemn and profound. It might have been the dry pulse of the decaying house itself, after a while it whirred and cleared its throat and struck six times."
 

Note the significance of "the decaying house itself"; here, the house becomes a symbol of the family.

"Jason told him, his sense of injury and impotence feeding upon its own sound, so that after a time he forgot his haste in the violent cumulation of his self justification and his outrage."
 

Note the significance of Jason's feeling "impotent" when, in the Jason chapter, he felt like a "man": "I'm a man, I can stand it."

"Of his niece he did not think at all, nor of the arbitrary valuation of money. Neither of them had had entity or individuality from him for ten years: together they merely symbolised the job in the bank of which he had been deprived before he ever got it."

"He [Jason] sat there for some time. He heard a clock strike the half hour, then people began to pass, in Sunday and easter clothes. Some looked at him as they passed, at the man sitting quietly behind the wheel of a small car, with his invisible life ravelled out about him like a wornout sock, and went on."

Guiding questions for class discussion:

• What is symbolic about the Confederate soldier in the town square?
• What is important about the fact that Dilsey emerges as the solid, strong presence within the Compson household?
• What is significant about the fact that it is Dilsey who sees the beginning and the end (of the novel and of the Compson family)?
• How would you describe Jason's power as head of the household in this chapter? Does Dilsey have power? How does it compare?

• Ask students to create a reading journal, noting details such as Faulkner's use of narrative structure/time, narrative voice/point of view, form, and character. In this journal, students should cite passages and raise questions for class discussion. Collect the journal at the end of the curriculum unit.
• Ask students to note the major events detailed throughout the Dilsey chapter and arrange them chronologically.
• Students may write a brief essay or reading journal entry on one of the following questions, citing at least three examples from the text:
  • How does Dilsey's sense of time differ from that of Benjy, Quentin, and Jason?
  • What are some major differences, as narrated in the Dilsey chapter, between 1928 (the time of Dilsey's chapter) and 1910 (the time of Quentin's chapter)? What do those differences reflect about the Compsons and their home in the South?

Assessment for the whole curriculum unit:

Essay

Assign a formal essay in which students will answer one of the following questions. Each essay should be written as an argument that is supported by key passages from the novel.

• How does Faulkner use narrative structure to develop his primary characters?
• How does the Compson family (and notions of family "blood") change throughout the course of the novel?
• How does Faulkner present time throughout the novel, and what is the relationship between narrative and symbolic time and the changing historical times in the early twentieth-century South?
• By the end of the novel, Mrs. Compson has forbidden the mention of Caddy's name. What is significant about the fact that Caddy does not have her own chapter (and that she is nameless by the end of the novel)?

Creative Writing

Deliberate obscurity, or as Conrad Aiken once said of Faulkner's work, "deliberately withheld meaning," forces the reader to unravel the novel's events over time, rendering plot less essential than character. Benjy's chapter provides hints and glimpses into the life of the family over the years as Benjy remembers them. In later chapters, the narrative for each chapter is more straightforward, allowing the reader to see how certain events occur sequentially. Caddy, however, never speaks for herself throughout the entire novel, even though she is a key character—perhaps the key character of the novel. Caddy is an enigma, to her brothers and to her readers, yet she is perhaps the most (tragically) heroic of the Compsons—certainly more so than the tragic Quentin (Chapter 2) or the rather villainous Jason (Chapter 3). Caddy escapes the South, although readers discover that she ultimately finds herself mixed up in a much more historically Modern problem.

With this context in mind, ask students to write part of a "Caddy Chapter" in the first person (4-5 pages). Students should include an introductory paragraph that explains how and why they are using the first person throughout the chapter, and their "Caddy Chapter" should unfold the same plot as presented throughout the novel via Caddy's imagined perspective.